-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%

CarMax (KMX) Earns A Top Value Rating, Is It Still Undervalued?

Simply Wall St·11/15/2026 04:34:14
Listen to the news

Recent research flagged CarMax (KMX) after it received a top-tier value stock rating, highlighting its low P/E and attractive PEG ratios compared with peers, alongside an earnings outlook that has caught value investors’ attention.

CarMax shares have been volatile, with a 1-day share price return of 1.22% and a 7-day gain of 3.38%, set against a 90-day share price decline of 9.07%. At the same time, the year-to-date share price return stands at 35.45% and the 1-year total shareholder return at 54.57%, which points to momentum that has cooled in the short term while the longer trend and recent value rating keep interest elevated.

Scan beyond CarMax and explore other value-focused opportunities using our hand-picked screener of 34 high quality undervalued stocks that share similar valuation appeal.

Bulls point to CarMax’s low P/E and value rating, while bears focus on past multi year share price declines and recent volatility. Which side does the valuation work actually support next?

Most Popular Narrative: 1.6% Undervalued

CarMax closed at $53.22, slightly below the narrative fair value estimate of $54.09. The gap hinges on how investors read recent management promises versus what actually showed up in the latest quarter. According to LunaRodas, an investor in the Simply Wall St Community, the key question is whether the pricing and margin story still lines up with the original plan.

The line worth reading sits beneath both numbers. The June pledge to fund lower prices through efficiency rather than margin now surfaces mainly in analyst answers, with a fiscal 2028 date, a softer verb, and two more quarters of lower margin in front of it. The controllable half bundles the pricing algorithm together with the margin given up to fund it, so the comp cannot say which one worked.

See why 1 investors see CarMax as 2% undervalued.

Result: Fair Value of $54.09 (ABOUT RIGHT)

Still, the CarMax story faces pressure if FTC tailwinds fade faster than expected or if management walks back its efficiency-over-margin promises again.

Find out about the key risks to this CarMax narrative.

Another View: CarMax Looks Expensive On Earnings

Flip the lens and the picture shifts. On a P/E of 25.8x, CarMax trades at a much richer level than both its peer group on 11.6x and the US Specialty Retail average on 16.9x, while the fair ratio sits at 19.9x. That gap points to valuation risk if sentiment cools.

For investors who lean on earnings multiples rather than narratives, this richer pricing raises a simple question. Does the recent 1-year share price run leave enough room for error, or does the story now demand almost flawless execution to hold up? See what the numbers say about this price — find out in our valuation breakdown.

NYSE:KMX P/E Ratio as at Nov 2026
NYSE:KMX P/E Ratio as at Nov 2026

Next Steps

Mixed signals around CarMax can pull you in either direction, so move quickly from headline takes to your own evidence based view using the full picture of 1 key reward and 3 important warning signs.

Looking For More Ideas Beyond CarMax?

Do not stop your research at CarMax. Broaden your watchlist with fresh stock ideas that fit different risk levels and income goals using focused screeners.