-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%
-+ 0.00%

The index removes the mystery: BlackRock (BLK.US) 120,000 shares Strategy (MSTR.US) may not be a sell order

Zhitongcaijing·11/19/2026 03:57:02
Listen to the news

According to Woofun AI, the Strategy (MSTR.US) position retention problem faced by BLK.US (BLK.US) funds due to the MSCI index adjustment is becoming the focus of market attention. As MSCI is due to remove Strategy from multiple indices after the close of trading on November 30, funds tracking these indices will have to readjust their portfolios, but BlackRock's 123,000 Strategy shares will not necessarily be converted into market sell orders; their final flow depends on the operating mechanism of the different funds.

Strategy's Class A shares are classified as “non-operating companies” under the MSCI USA Index (MSCI USA Index) framework, and are therefore subject to this exclusion. The change took effect on December 1. BlackRock's iShares MSCI USA ETF (code MLRG) directly tracks the index, and its public holdings show that as of November 13, the fund held 5,227 Strategy shares worth approximately $58.3 million. MLRG uses a representative sampling strategy, which means that managers do not need to hold every stock in the index, but rather select a set of portfolios to match the index's performance. The recruitment prospectus allows managers to hold off-index investments when they help track the index, including arrangements for changes in expected components. Therefore, although Strategy's exit constituted a reason for the adjustment, the document did not require that all 5,227 shares be sold at once at the close of the market on November 30, and the manager had greater operational flexibility.

In contrast, BlackRock's other fund, the iShares MSCI USA Swap UCITS ETF (traded under the MUSD code in Europe), tracks the same MSCI US Index, but its operating mechanism is quite different. MUSD does not directly copy index constituent stocks, but rather obtains index performance through total income swap agreements signed with financial institutions. The fund uses a set of developed market stocks as collateral to exchange profits from the MSCI US Index to counterparties. When Strategy is removed from the index, it no longer contributes to the performance of the index delivered by the contract, but this does not mean that MUSD must sell any Strategy shares it may hold. Since contract details and counterparty risk adjustments are not disclosed in fund documents, it is impossible to estimate the specific number of shares the fund must sell based on MUSD's asset size and Strategy's weight in the index alone. This invisibility makes it difficult for the market to accurately assess its potential selling pressure.

According to data compiled by Woofun AI, the holdings of BlackRock's three major funds are more clear. The iShares MSCI World ETF (URTH) tracks developed market companies and declared 293,000 Strategy shares worth about $3.3 million on November 13; iShares MSCI ACWI ETF tracks developed and emerging market companies and declared 88,500 shares worth about $9.9 million on the same day. Since these broad-based indices include the US portion, Strategy's removal from the MSCI US Index will also affect them. Together with MLRG's 5,227 shares, the three funds together hold 123,000 Strategy shares, with a total value of $13.74 million. URTH and ACWI both use representative sampling, and managers also have a certain degree of freedom when matching the index, so the change of 123,000 shares is not a simple linear selling process, but rather complex adjustments scattered across different fund strategies.

Furthermore, edge cases and macroscopic data further reveal the complexity of the problem. iShares ESG Advanced MSCI USA ETF (USXF) tracks an MSCI US version with additional screening rules and declared 161,000 Strategy shares on November 13, but as of November 17, the standard index announcement has not yet clarified how to adjust this special version. MSCI's announcement for specific indices is scheduled to be issued on November 18, so USXF is not included in the above total. On the other hand, Invesco QQQ, which tracks Nasdaq-100, is not affected by MSCI rules and is included independently of the rules. According to official Strategy data, the funds tracking the MSCI Global Investable Index hold a total of about 13 million shares, which is equivalent to 3.1% of the basic tradable shares. This figure is far larger than the sample of BlackRock's three funds, but the specific holding dates and fund lists have not been disclosed, increasing the uncertainty of market predictions.

A decrease in the number of positions is not equivalent to someone selling in the secondary market. The size of ETFs fluctuates due to investors' subscriptions or redemptions. When the size of the fund is reduced, some stocks may leave through the share redemption process, and financial institutions return the fund shares to the ETF in exchange for underlying securities. At this time, Strategy shares can be transferred to other institutions without the fund being sold on the exchange. The next position file will only record smaller positions, without revealing where these stocks will go next. MUSD's contract structure further limits observability, and counterparty adjustments cannot be directly reflected through fund positions. Even if changes in positions can be seen, it is difficult to tell how much of the stock price fluctuation is driven by MSCI, especially when investors can trade early. Strategy will eventually lose its place in the performance targets of these funds, which may weaken demand for its shares, and in turn affect the financing appeal of Michael Saylor's securities company, which buys bitcoins, but the index exclusion itself does not require Strategy to sell any bitcoins.