At the 24% bracket, bank dividends usually qualify for the 15% rate. A $500,000 portfolio spread across five regional banks makes about $18,540 a year in dividends, and a taxable account sends $2,781 of that to the IRS every year.
The same dividends stay untaxed in a Roth IRA. Under 26 U.S.C. § 408A(d)(1), qualified Roth distributions are excluded from gross income. IRS Publication 590-B for tax year 2025 says a distribution qualifies once the 5-year period has passed and the owner is at least 59½. That covers most retired people.
Roth Versus Taxable: $500,000 Across Five BanksThe model below puts $100,000 in each bank and uses current yields. Payout ratio (the share of earnings paid out as dividends) is trailing dividends divided by trailing EPS.
Bank Yield Income per $100K Payout Ratio U.S. Bancorp (NYSE:USB) 3.48% $3,480 41% Truist Financial (NYSE:TFC) 4.2% $4,200 55% KeyCorp (NYSE:KEY) 3.86% $3,860 46% Citizens Financial Group (NYSE:CFG) 2.92% $2,920 38% Huntington Bancshares (NASDAQ:HBAN) 4.08% $4,080 51% Account Gross Income Tax at 15% Net Income Taxable $18,540 $2,781 $15,759 Roth IRA $18,540 $0 $18,540The Roth saves $2,781 more each year. Over 10 years, with no growth assumed, that adds up to $27,810.
Dividend Safety Check on Each BankU.S. Bancorp raised its quarterly dividend to $0.54 from $0.52 and posted an 18.5% ROTCE (profit relative to tangible equity). Each raise adds to income that grows untaxed in a Roth. Risk: Q3 revenue of $7.97 billion missed expectations.
Truist has paid $0.52 a quarter since August 2022. It has the highest yield of the five, so it saves the most tax in a Roth. The risk is that it posts the highest payout ratio in the group, and Q3 included a $1.4 billion pre-tax loss on securities sales.
KeyCorp has held its dividend at $0.205 since late 2022, while EPS rose from $0.35 to $0.51 over five quarters. Its net interest margin (loan yield minus deposit cost) widened to 2.95%. Risk: revenue missed expectations in the last two quarters.
Citizens Financial raised its dividend 13% to $0.52. Net charge-offs (loans written off) fell to 37 bps from 46 bps. Risk: its trailing yield is the lowest of the five, so it adds the least to the Roth advantage today.
Huntington has paid $0.155 every quarter since December 2021, including while it took over Cadence and Veritex. Risk: annualized net charge-offs rose to 0.31%.
How Your Bracket Changes the Roth AdvantageSingle taxpayers with income above $200,000 and joint taxpayers above $250,000 also owe the 3.8% net investment income tax. In 2026, the 32% bracket starts at $403,550 for married couples, which is above that threshold.
Ordinary Bracket Dividend Rate Taxable Net Roth Advantage 22% 15% $15,759 $2,781 24% 15% $15,759 $2,781 32% 18.8% $15,054 $3,486 37% 23.8% $14,127 $4,413 What 20 Years Outside a Roth CostsSay the annual $2,781 difference is reinvested at a conservative 4%, and share prices stay flat. Over 10 years it grows to $33,389, and over 20 years to $82,813. At the 23.8% top rate, the 20-year figure is $131,396. That is income lost for good when these banks are held outside a retirement account.
Three Moves Before Your Next Tax Filing