Air Canada has delivered a 21.0% gain over the past three years, and a fresh round of deal making around its Aeroplan loyalty program now puts the focus squarely on what investors are paying for its earnings. With the stock recently closing at $21.68, the question is whether that price still lines up with the profits the airline is generating.
The stock's next move may depend on whether Air Canada's current price is justified by the earnings investors are effectively paying for today.
If you want a wider starting point for ideas tied to earnings power, it can help to compare Air Canada with other companies in the 3 high quality undervalued stocks.
The P/E ratio works well for Air Canada because earnings are front and centre for how investors judge airlines. At a current P/E of 18.0x, the stock trades below the peer group average of 21.7x and above the broader airlines sector, which is around 11.1x. That puts Air Canada on a richer multiple than the typical carrier but at a discount to a closer peer set that investors actually use to price the stock.
Because the fair P/E implied by the valuation model is higher than where Air Canada trades today, this framework points to the shares looking undervalued on earnings. The CA$2.5b Aeroplan sale has sharpened attention on profit quality and balance sheet strength, yet even after that deal the market still prices the airline at a lower multiple than the model suggests might be warranted for its risk and return profile. Explore the numbers behind Air Canada's P/E valuation.
Simply Wall St Narratives pick up where the P/E puzzle for Air Canada leaves off and explain which growth, margin and earnings paths would need to occur for the share price to sit meaningfully above or below where it trades today. Rather than focusing on a single multiple or model output, each narrative lays out the assumptions that drive its view of fair value so you can compare those inputs with Air Canada's actual results as they are reported.
Bulls and bears looking at Air Canada are reading the same facts and coming away with very different valuation stories.
Bull case: 26% undervalued
The analyst consensus Narrative on Simply Wall St sees more upside if Air Canada can turn its current plan into sturdier profits.
"Fleet modernization and upcoming entry of next generation fuel efficient aircraft, including deliveries of 2 787-10s, 9 A321XLRs and 16 A220s in 2026, with a targeted 100 basis points of margin expansion from fuel efficiency, are expected to support lower unit costs and operating margins..."
Discover why this Narrative puts Air Canada at 26% undervalued.
Bear case: 20% overvalued
The bearish analyst Narrative on Simply Wall St leans into cost pressure and a tougher operating backdrop for Air Canada.
"Even though Air Canada expects nearly 100 basis points of margin benefit from fleet modernization as A321XLRs, A220s and 787 10s arrive over the next 36 months, the combination of a 5% to 6% full year 2026 adjusted CASM increase and elevated gross CapEx of $3.6b for 2026 creates a risk that fuel efficiency gains are overwhelmed by higher unit costs and capital intensity, which could restrain any improvement in operating margins and free cash flow..."
Explore why this Narrative puts Air Canada at 20% overvalued.
Numbers only tell part of the story for Air Canada, because the people setting priorities, taking risks and deciding their own rewards can tilt long term outcomes in ways the P/E never shows. See who runs Air Canada and how they are paid.
Have feedback on this article? Concerned about the content? Get in touch with us directly. Alternatively, email editorial-team@simplywallst.com